Which...oh, how funny. We were doing this with Red Sox players just last night at the game!
David Ortiz = Mr. Eko (they both wield big sticks)
Jason Varitek = Jack (they actually sound alike)
Manny Ramirez = Hurley (dude!)
Arod (ok, so he's a Yankee) = Sawyer
Curt Schilling = Locke (don't tell me what I can't do!)
Kevin Millar = Shannon (annoying and now, thankfully, GONE)
Johnny Damon = Michael (once on our side, now on the enemy's side)
...I think we had some more but that's all I can remember right now...